JMU JMIR Mhealth Uhealth JMIR mHealth and uHealth 2291-5222 JMIR Publications Toronto, Canada v7i11e13741 31719023 10.2196/13741 Original Paper Original Paper Exploring the Patterns of Use and Acceptability of Mobile Phones Among People Living With HIV to Improve Care and Treatment: Cross-Sectional Study in Three Francophone West African Countries Eysenbach Gunther Garfein Richard Stasiak Karolina Mendes David Lepère Phillipe MPH 1
Institut de Santé Globale Université de Genève, Suisse 24 rue du Général-Dufour 1205 Genève Genève Switzerland 41 +33673777280 lepere.p@wanadoo.fr
https://orcid.org/0000-0002-1552-4996 Touré Yélamikan MD 2 https://orcid.org/0000-0002-3620-2523 Bitty-Anderson Alexandra M MPH 2 https://orcid.org/0000-0002-0525-0100 Boni Simon P MD 2 https://orcid.org/0000-0002-0630-9135 Anago Gildas MSc 2 https://orcid.org/0000-0002-6875-8016 Tchounga Boris MPH, PhD, MD 2 https://orcid.org/0000-0002-8747-9610 Touré Pendadiago BA 3 https://orcid.org/0000-0002-8812-8433 Minga Albert MD, PhD 4 https://orcid.org/0000-0003-2357-6902 Messou Eugène MD, PhD 5 https://orcid.org/0000-0002-9495-0618 Kanga Guillaume MD 6 https://orcid.org/0000-0002-1019-8802 Koule Serge MD 7 https://orcid.org/0000-0003-0926-7687 Poda Armel PhD 8 https://orcid.org/0000-0002-7463-9179 Calmy Alexandra MD, PhD 9 https://orcid.org/0000-0002-1137-6826 Ekouevi Didier K MPH, MD, PhD 2 10 11 12 https://orcid.org/0000-0001-7644-9902 Coffie Patrick A MPH, MD, PhD 2 13 14 https://orcid.org/0000-0002-6486-2991 Institut de Santé Globale Université de Genève, Suisse Genève Switzerland Programme PACCI Abidjan Cote D'Ivoire Centre Solidarité Actions Sociales Bouaké Cote D'Ivoire Centre Médical de Suivi des donneurs de sang Abidjan Cote D'Ivoire Entre de Prise en charge et de Formation à Yopougon-Attié Abidjan Cote D'Ivoire Centre Intégré de Recherches Biocliniques d'Abidjan Abidjan Cote D'Ivoire Unité de soins ambulatoires et de conseils Abidjan Cote D'Ivoire Hôpital de Jour Service des Maladies Infectieuses et Tropicales CHU Souro Sanou Bobo Dioulasso Burkina Faso Unité Virus de L'immunodéficience Humaine Service des maladies infectieuses Hôpital Universitaire de Genève Genève Switzerland Centre Africain de Recherche en Epidémiologie et en Santé Publique Lomé Togo Département Santé Publique Université de Lomé Lomé Togo Centre Inserm - 1219 Université de Bordeaux Bordeaux France Département de Dermatologie et d’Infectiologie Unités de Formation et de Recherche des Sciences Médicales Université Félix Houphouët Boigny, Abidjan Cote D'Ivoire Service des Maladies Infectieuses et Tropicales Centre Hospitalier Universitaire de Treichville Abidjan Cote D'Ivoire Corresponding Author: Phillipe Lepère lepere.p@wanadoo.fr 11 2019 13 11 2019 7 11 e13741 21 2 2019 18 4 2019 7 6 2019 19 6 2019 ©Phillipe Lepère, Yélamikan Touré, Alexandra M Bitty-Anderson, Simon P Boni, Gildas Anago, Boris Tchounga, Pendadiago Touré, Albert Minga, Eugène Messou, Guillaume Kanga, Serge Koule, Armel Poda, Alexandra Calmy, Didier K Ekouevi, Patrick A Coffie. Originally published in JMIR Mhealth and Uhealth (http://mhealth.jmir.org), 13.11.2019. 2019

This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work, first published in JMIR mhealth and uhealth, is properly cited. The complete bibliographic information, a link to the original publication on http://mhealth.jmir.org/, as well as this copyright and license information must be included.

 Background

The use of mobile technology in health care (mobile health [mHealth]) could be an innovative way to improve health care, especially for increasing retention in HIV care and adherence to treatment. However, there is a scarcity of studies on mHealth among people living with HIV (PLHIV) in West and Central Africa.

 Objective

The aim of this study was to assess the acceptability of an mHealth intervention among PLHIV in three countries of West Africa.

 Methods

A cross-sectional study among PLHIV was conducted in 2017 in three francophone West African countries: Côte d’Ivoire, Burkina Faso, and Togo. PLHIV followed in the six preselected HIV treatment and care centers, completed a standardized questionnaire on mobile phone possession, acceptability of mobile phone for HIV care and treatment, preference of mobile phone services, and phone sharing. Descriptive statistics and logistic regression were used to describe variables and assess factors associated with mHealth acceptability.

 Results

A total of 1131 PLHIV—643 from Côte d’Ivoire, 239 from Togo, and 249 from Burkina Faso—participated in the study. Median age was 44 years, and 76.1% were women (n=861). Almost all participants owned a mobile phone (n=1107, 97.9%), and 12.6% (n=140) shared phones with a third party. Acceptability of mHealth was 98.8%, with the majority indicating their preference for both phone calls and text messages. Factors associated with mHealth acceptability were having a primary school education or no education (adjusted odds ratio=7.15, 95% CI 5.05-10.12; P<.001) and waiting over one hour before meeting a medical doctor on appointment day (adjusted odds ratio=1.84, 95% CI 1.30-2.62; P=.01).

 Conclusions

The use of mHealth in HIV treatment and care is highly acceptable among PLHIV and should be considered a viable tool to allow West and Central African countries to achieve the Joint United Nations Programme on HIV/AIDS 90-90-90 goals.

 acceptability mHealth PLHIV West Africa Introduction

In 2017, the number of people living with HIV (PLHIV) was estimated to be approximately 36.9 million people worldwide, and the number of new HIV infections was estimated to be 1.8 million [1]. In the fight against the HIV epidemic, considerable progress has been made, including an increase in the number of patients on treatment, a decrease in the number of new infections, and a reduction in morbidity and mortality [1]. The Joint United Nations Programme on HIV/AIDS (UNAIDS) Fast-Track proposes a framework for achieving a set of ambitious targets for HIV prevention (reduce the number of new infections to <500,000), treatment (reduce the number of AIDS-related deaths to <500,000), and zero discrimination by 2020. As part of this strategy, the world has embraced the 90-90-90 treatment target for the post-2015 era, setting the goal that by 2020, 90% of all PLHIV know their HIV status, 90% of all people with diagnosed HIV infection receive sustained antiretroviral therapy (ART), and 90% of all people receiving ART have durable viral suppression [2].

Today, if treatment is initiated early, adherence is maintained, and quality of care is high, the life expectancy of a person living with HIV is nearly the same as that of a person without HIV [3]. This is true in high-income countries and low-/middle-income countries where some disparities still exist between men and women [4]. As a result, HIV infection is increasingly becoming a chronic disease. Within this paradigm of HIV as a chronic disease, mobile technology can help health systems improve the quality of the HIV treatment cascade. In addition, the World Health Organization (WHO) has endorsed text messaging or short messages service (SMS) interventions for supporting individual-level adherence to ART and for improving linkage of people diagnosed with HIV to HIV-care services [5]. A WHO survey reported that 83% of the Member States used a mobile health (mHealth) initiative for promoting HIV issues [6].

Several pilot projects using mHealth for infectious diseases such as tuberculosis, malaria, and Ebola and for chronic diseases such as hypertension and diabetes have been proven to be feasible and acceptable in the African context, demonstrating the potential of mHealth in contributing to chronic patients’ treatment and care [7-12]. These technologies are also used in HIV treatment and care to improve retention in care and adherence to treatment, which are major challenges to care programs in sub-Saharan Africa, where retention is estimated to be less than 75% at 12 months and 60% at 24 months [13,14]. A systematic review of SMS interventions found that 73% of the studies used “SMS only” interventions, and in only 27% of studies, the use of SMS was associated with other interventions [15]. In sub-Saharan Africa, most interventions using mHealth have mainly used SMS as a way to improve retention of PLHIV in care and adherence to ART. In Cameroon, two interventions among PLHIV used text messages to improve adherence: one used once-per-week motivational messages and the other used four-times-per-week educational messages [16]. Another study in South Africa used an electronic adherence monitoring device and text reminders if patients were late in taking their medications [17]. Text messages reminders for appointments were used to assess retention among PLHIV in Mozambique and were found to improve retention among urban patients and those who newly initiated ART [18].

As part of the standard of care, some interventions were used to improve retention and adherence such as phone calls to patients missing their appointments and home visits in some countries [19]. However, home visits and phone calls, despite their relative effectiveness, constitute a significant financial burden and are not sustainable in the long term [20]. mHealth interventions could decrease this financial burden, especially since mobile phone penetration in sub-Saharan Africa is high and represents an opportunity for the continent [21]. Therefore, there is a need to identify simple, acceptable, and sustainable interventions to improve retention in care and adherence to ART for PLHIV. As a systematic review of mHealth interventions in Africa indicated, successful mHealth interventions would yield positive outcomes if they are accessible, accepted, and low cost while adaptable to the local context [20].

In sub-Saharan Africa, the scientific literature on mHealth has been concentrated in East and Southern Africa, while there is a scarcity of studies in West Africa, especially francophone West Africa countries [22]. A systematic review of mHealth interventions in low-and middle-income countries identified 34 publications from Africa, only two of which were from West Africa including one from a francophone country [22]. Before suggesting mHealth interventions, it is essential to assess the acceptability and feasibility of an mHealth intervention in HIV care and treatment among PLHIV in francophone West Africa. The aim of this study was to explore the social and financial acceptability, which has not been reported yet in Francophone Africa, and the feasibility of an mHealth intervention for the improvement of care among PLHIV in West Africa. We hypothesize that the rates of acceptability would be similar to that found in other regions of Africa.

 Methods Study Design and Setting

A cross-sectional study was conducted from September to December 2017 in three francophone West African countries: Côte d’Ivoire, Burkina Faso, and Togo. Six HIV clinics in Côte d’Ivoire, one HIV clinic in Burkina Faso, and one HIV clinic in Togo participated in the study. These centers are reference centers for the three countries, with a significant number of PLHIV in care.

 Participants

Inclusion criteria were age≥18 years, receiving ART for at least 1 year, and receiving follow-up at one of the HIV clinics participating in the study. Participants were selected in each clinic by using a systematic random sampling procedure. Each day of the survey, eligibility criteria for the study were checked by a social worker. Sequential numbers were issued to eligible participants in the order in which they arrived at the HIV clinic. The first eligible participant of the day was included, and a sampling interval of five was applied to select subsequent participants. This procedure was repeated every day in each participating HIV clinic. To avoid possible duplicates, each selected participant received a marked sticker on his medical record.

 Study Size

We hypothesized that mHealth coverage would be around 80% according to the results from previous studies conducted in sub-Saharan Africa [23,24-25]. Considering a relative risk of α=5% and a precision of 5% of the value of the expected acceptability, and taking into account an assumption of 10% of missing data, based on the formula n=z2 p(1-p)/α2 (with z= confidence level; p=estimated proportion of mHealth coverage in sub-Saharan Africa; α=precision level) for estimation of the sample size, the minimum sample size was estimated at 246 PLHIV on ART in each of the three participating countries for a total of 738 PLHIV [26]. This allowed comparison of the acceptability of mHealth per country.

 Data Collection

A questionnaire was elaborated by a multidisciplinary team of epidemiologists, clinicians, sociologists, social workers, and members of networks of PLHIV. After obtaining informed consent, this standardized questionnaire was administered face-to-face to each participant by trained social workers involved in HIV care and treatment using classical pen and paper material. The questionnaire explored five aspects: sociodemographic characteristics, HIV characteristics, possession of mobile phone, phone sharing, and acceptability (of mobile health). The main outcomes for this study were possession of a phone and acceptability of mHealth (phone calls/text messages).

 Statistical Analysis

The data collected were entered into a Microsoft Access 2013 database (Microsoft Corporation, Redmond, WA) developed for this purpose. Data analysis was performed using STATA (version 11.0; Stata Corp, College Station, Texas). Quantitative variables were described using means and medians, while categorical variables were describing using numbers and proportions. Kruskall-Wallis and Wilcoxon nonparametric tests were used to compare medians for quantitative variables. Chi-square or Fisher exact tests were used to compare categorical variables. Univariate and multivariate regression analyses were carried out to assess factors associated with acceptability of text messages or phone calls to improve health conditions. Regression analyses assessed the factors associated with the acceptability of mHealth on the basis of the towns (Abidjan, Bouaké, Bobo-Dioulasso, and Lomé).

 Ethical Considerations

The protocol for this study was approved by the National Ethics Committee of the Ministry of Health in Côte d’Ivoire, Togo, and Burkina-Faso.

 Results Sociodemographic Characteristics

A total of 1131 PLHIV from Côte d’Ivoire (n=643, 56.9%), Togo (n=239, 21.1%), and Burkina Faso (n=249, 22.0%), with a median age of 44 years (interquartile range [IQR]=38-51; Côte d'Ivoire: median=43, IQR=38-50; Burkina-Faso: median=43, IQR: 38-50; Togo: median=44, IQR=37-49; P=.04) participated in the study. Among them, 861 (76.1%) were women and about half (n=578, 51.1%) were single. A total of 640 (56.6%) participants had no formal education or a primary educational level and nearly one-third (n=393, 34.7%) could not read or write. Participants from Burkina Faso had the lowest rate of literacy, with 65.1% (n=162) of PLHIV being unable to read and write compared to 25.5% (n=61) from Togo and 26.4% (n=170) from Côte d’Ivoire (P<.001). The monthly income of three-quarter of the participants (n=837, 74.0%) was less than 60,000 Franc Communauté Financière Africaine (FCFA) (approximately US $120), which corresponds to the minimum wage in most countries of francophone West Africa. With regard to the HIV treatment status, 785 (69.4%) had been on ART for over 5 years. Other patient characteristics are summarized in Table 1.

The sociodemographic characteristics of patients in the three participating countries (N=1131).

Characteristic  Côte d'Ivoire(n=643), n (%) Burkina-Faso(n=249), n (%) Togo(n=239), n (%) Total(N=1131), n (%) P value
Age (years) .02
18-34 80 (12.4) 23 (9.2) 38 (15.9) 141 (12.5)  
35-49 363 (56.5) 160 (64.3) 148 (61.9) 671 (59.3)  
≥50 200 (31.1) 66 (26.5) 53 (22.2) 319 (28.2)  
Sex <.001
Male 179 (27.8) 40 (16.1) 51 (21.3) 270 (23.9)  
Female 464 (72.2) 209 (83.9) 188 (78.7) 861 (76.1)  
Marital status .07
Single 335 (52.1) 112 (45.0) 131 (54.8) 578 (51.1)  
In a relationship 308 (47.9) 137 (55.0) 108 (45.2) 553 (48.9)  
Level of education <.001
No education and primary school 312 (48.5) 194 (77.9) 134 (56.1) 640 (56.6)  
Secondary school and university 331 (51.5) 55 (22.1) 105 (43.9) 491 (43.4)  
Literacy <.001
Can read or write 473 (73.6) 87 (34.9) 178 (74.5) 738 (65.3)
Cannot read or write 170 (26.4) 162 (65.1) 61 (25.5) 393 (34.7)
Monthly income (in FCFAa,b) <.001
<60,000 400 (62.2) 222 (89.2) 215 (90.0) 837 (74.0)  
60,000-199,999 176 (27.4) 24 (9.6) 20 (8.3) 220 (19.5)  
>200,000 67 (10.4) 3 (1.2) 4 (1.7) 74 (6.5)  
Duration of antiretroviral therapy (years) <.001
<5 202 (31.4) 59 (23.7) 85 (35.6) 346 (30.6)  
5-10 207 (32.2) 135 (54.2) 101 (42.3) 443 (39.2)  
>10 234 (36.4) 55 (22.1) 53 (22.1) 342 (30.2)  

aUS $1=576.90 FCFA; 60,000 FCFA is the minimum wage in most West African countries.

bFCFA: Franc Communauté Financière Africaine.

 Mobile Phone Possession and Access to the Internet

Table 2 summarizes mobile phone possession, mobile internet access, and phone sharing. Overall, the rate of mobile phone possession was 97.9% (n=1107), with a small difference between countries (98.8%, 95.6%, and 97.9% for Côte d’Ivoire, Burkina Faso, and Togo, respectively; P=.01). More men owned a mobile phone than women (99.6% vs 97.3%; P=.03). With regard to the level of education status, more PLHIV who could read or write possessed phones than PLHIV who could not read or write (99.4% vs 96.7%; P=.002). A total of 140 (12.6%) participants shared phones with somebody: 15.4% (n=99) in Côte d’Ivoire, 8.0% (n=20) in Burkina Faso, 8.8% (n=21) in Togo (P=.002). Mobile phone sharing was also higher among women and among those with high monthly incomes.

Among PLHIV, 282 (25.5%) had mobile internet access: 30.7% (n=195) from Côte d’Ivoire, 29.9% (n=70) from Togo, and 7.1% (n=17) from Burkina Faso (P<.001). Most of those who had a secondary school or university education had better mobile internet access, including young people, women, and those with a higher monthly income (n=208, 42.6%; P<.001).

Among mobile phone owners, 33.4% (n=370) owned a smartphone, with a significant difference between countries (73.5%, 3.3%, and 23.2% for Côte d’Ivoire, Burkina Faso, and Togo, respectively; P<.001). Among those who owned a smartphone, 83.7% (n=236) had access to mobile internet through mobile phones, with a difference between countries (71.2%, 2.5%, and 26.3% for Côte d’Ivoire, Burkina Faso and Togo respectively; P<.001).

Description of mobile phone possession among patients living with HIV in the three participating countries (N=1131).

Description Mobile phone possession  (n=1107) Internet access on mobile phone (n=282) Mobile phone sharing with someone else (n=140)
n (%) P value n (%) P value n (%) P value
Country N/Aa 0.013 N/A <.001 N/A 0.002
  Côte d’Ivoire 635 (98.8) N/A 195 (30.7) N/A 99 (15.4) N/A
  Burkina Faso 238 (95.6) N/A 17 (7.1) N/A 20 (8.0) N/A
  Togo 234 (97.9) N/A 70 (29.9) N/A 21 (8.8) N/A
Age (years) N/A 0.31 N/A <.001 N/A 0.59
  18-34 136 (96.5) N/A 61 (44.9) N/A 20 (14.2) N/A
  35-49 660 (98.4) N/A 175 (26.5) N/A 85 (12.7) N/A
  ≥50 311 (97.5) N/A 46 (14.8) N/A 35 (11.0) N/A
Sex N/A 0.03 N/A <.001 N/A 0.03
  Male 269 (99.6) N/A 106 (39.4) N/A 23 (16.4) N/A
  Female 838 (97.3) N/A 176 (21.0) N/A 117 (83.6) N/A
Marital status N/A 0.26 N/A 0.38 N/A 0.24
  Single 563 (97.4) N/A 137 (24.3) N/A 65 (11.3) N/A
  In a relationship 544 (98.4) N/A 145 (26.7) N/A 75 (13.6) N/A
Level of education N/A 0.002 N/A <.001 N/A 0.89
  No education and primary school 619 (96.7) N/A 74 (12.0) N/A 80 (12.5) N/A
  Secondary school and university 488 (99.4) N/A 208 (42.6) N/A 60 (12.2) N/A
Literacy N/A <.001 N/A <.001 N/A 0.51
  Can read or write 733 (99.3) N/A 256 (34.9) N/A 95 (12.9) N/A
  Cannot read or write 374 (95.2) N/A 26 (7.0) N/A 45 (11.5) N/A
Monthly income (in FCFAb,c) N/A 0.18 N/A <.001 N/A . 01
  <60,000 815 (97.4) N/A 147 (18.0) N/A 91 (10.9) N/A
  60,000-200,000 218 (99.1) N/A 92 (42.2) N/A 33 (15.0) N/A
  >200,000 74 (100.0) N/A 43 (58.1) N/A 16 (21.6) N/A
Duration of antiretroviral therapy (years) N/A 0.25 N/A 0.04 N/A 0.34
  <5 335 (96.8) N/A 97 (29.0) N/A 48 (13.9) N/A
  5-10 435 (98.2) N/A 93 (21.4) N/A 47 (10.6) N/A
  >10 337 (98.5) N/A 92 (27.3) N/A 45 (13.2) N/A

aN/A: not applicable.

bUS $1=576.90 FCFA; 60,000 FCFA is the minimum wage in most West African countries.

cFCFA: Franc Communauté Financière Africaine.

 Mobile Health Acceptability and Preferred Way of Communication

The overall rate of mHealth acceptability (patients’ acceptability of receiving text messages or phone calls from their physicians) was 98.8% with no variation by country (98.3% in Côte d’Ivoire, 99.1% in Togo, and 100.0% in Burkina Faso; P=.08). A total of 386 (34.9%), 708 (63.9%), and 11 (1.0%) patients were willing to receive phone calls only, text messages and phone calls, and text messages only, respectively. Thus, there was a total of 1083 (97.8%) PLHIV who wished to receive phone calls and 708 (63.9%) who wished to receive text messages and phone calls.

There was no statistically significant difference between countries for preference for phone calls (n=618 [57.1%], n=234 [21.6%], and n=231 [21.3%] in Côte d’Ivoire, Burkina Faso, and Togo, respectively; P=.47) and for sex (n=260 [24.0%] and n=823 [for men and women, respectively; P=.12).

Among participants who preferred text messages, 60.7% (n=430) had a secondary or higher education level, while 39.3% (n=278) had a lower educational level (P<.001). Conversely, 56.1% (n=607) of those who preferred phone calls had primary school level or no educational background (P=.55).

 Financial Acceptability and Willingness to Pay

Financial acceptability (answers to the question, “How much would you be willing to spend per month, if you could contact your health care worker for your care?”) was also considered, with 50.1% (n=322), 88.7% (n=212), and 92.8% (n=231) of PLHIV in Côte d’Ivoire, Togo, and Burkina Faso, respectively, likely to financially support out-of-pocket expenditures generated by the adoption of a mHealth solution, if any. The options given for the level of monthly contribution each patient was willing to pay for a mHealth intervention varied from 0 to 3000 FCFA (nearly US $0 to $6). A total of 20.1% (n=227) of PLHIV were willing to pay less than 1000 FCFA (nearly US $2), 35.7% (n=404) were willing to pay between 1000 and 3000 FCFA (nearly US $2 to $6), and 11.8% (n=134) were willing to pay more than 3000 FCFA (>US $6). However, there was no significant relationship between financial acceptability and monthly income: 67.4% (n=362) of those who had less than the minimum wage were willing to financially contribute to mHealth costs, and 68.4 (n=201) of those who had more than the minimum wage were also willing to financially contribute to mHealth costs (P=.47).

 Factors Associated With Mobile Health Acceptability

In multivariate analysis, factors significantly associated with acceptability of “phone calls” to improve HIV treatment and care were as follows: living in Bouaké, the second town of Côte d’Ivoire (adjusted odds ratio [aOR]=6.24, 95% CI 3.98-9.79; P<.001), in Lomé (aOR=0.57, 95% CI 0.37-0.88; P<.01), or in Bobo-Dioulasso (aOR=3.06, 95% CI 2.11-4.43; P<.001); having a primary school education or no education (aOR=7.15, 95% CI 5.05-10.12; P<.001), and waiting over 1 hour before meeting a medical doctor on the appointment day (aOR=1.84, 95% CI 1.30-2.62; P=.01; Table 3).

Factors associated with acceptability of “phone calls” among patients living with HIV in the three participating countries (N=1111).

 Factor Total, n (%) Bivariate analysis  Multivariate analysis
      ORa 95% CI P value OR 95% CI P value
Town
  Abidjan (Côte d’Ivoire) 478 (43.0) 1     1    
  Bouaké (Côte d'Ivoire) 150 (13.5) 7.95 5.29-11.95 <.001 6.24 3.98-9.79 <.001
  Lomé (Togo) 234 (21.1) 0.95 0.63-1.40 0.8 0.56 0.36-0.87 0.011
  Bobo-Dioulasso (Burkina Faso) 249 (22.4) 5.28 3.77-7.39 <.001 3.06 2.11-4.43 <.001
Age (years)
  18-34 136 (12.2) 1          
  35-49 659 (59.3) 1.44 0.95-2.17 0.08 N/Ab N/A N/A
  ≥50 316 (28.4) 1.53 0.98-2.38 0.06 N/A N/A N/A
Sex
  Male 264 (23.8) 1          
  Female 847 (76.2) 1.84 1.34-2.51 <.001 N/A N/A N/A
Marital status
  Single 566 (50.9) 1          
  In a relationship 545 (49.0) 1.05 0.82-1.34 0.69 N/A N/A N/A
Level of education
  Secondary school and university 480 (43.2) 1     1    
  No education and primary school 631 (56.8) 8.83 6.3-12.22 <.001 7.14 5.04-10.10 <.001
Time to go to the health center (hours)
  ≤1 765 (68.8) 1          
  >1 346 (31.1) 1.15 0.88-1.50 0.29 N/A N/A N/A
Time to meet a doctor (hours)
  ≤1 330 (29.7) 1     1    
  >1 781 (70.3) 1.53 1.16-2.03 0.003 1.84 1.29-2.62 <.001
Monthly income (in FCFAc,d)
  <60,000 824 (74.2) 1          
  60,000-199,999 215 (19.3) 0.43 0.30-0.61 <.001 N/A N/A N/A
  >200,000 72 (6.5) 0.18 0.08-0.40 <.001 N/A N/A N/A

aOR: odds ratio.

bN/A: not applicable.

cUS $1=576.90 FCFA; 60,000 FCFA=minimum wage in most West African countries.

dFCFA:Franc Communauté Financière Africaine.

 Discussion Principal Findings

This study on PLHIV is the first one conducted in francophone sub-Saharan Africa that explores the acceptability of introducing an mHealth solution to better manage HIV treatment and care. In this study, almost all PLHIV reported their acceptability to introduce mHealth into their treatment and care. In addition, acceptability of mHealth was not dependent on sex, age, and level of literacy despite majority of the sample being illiterate. The level of literacy was not a barrier to the acceptability of mHealth, as demonstrated by the fact that almost all indicated their acceptability of mHealth, although the level of literacy conditioned the choice of mHealth services.

Consistent with our findings, previous studies conducted in East and Southern Africa have found the use of mobile phones in the framework of HIV treatment and care acceptable. A 2007 study in South Africa among 300 PLHIV explored the patterns of mobile phone use to improve adherence to ART and reported that 81% had a mobile phone, 99% indicated their acceptability for verbal clinic contact through their mobile phones, and 96% agreed to contact through text messages [27]. The same trend was observed in Kenya, where 99% of the sample supported the use of mobile technology in the management of HIV infection, with calls being the preferred method [28]. Those results suggest that the integration of mobile phone into the treatment and care of PLHIV in sub-Saharan Africa is an opportunity that should be considered.

Our study reported a mobile phone possession rate of 97.9% despite an unequal mobile network coverage across the three countries and confirmed important disparities in access to mobile internet between the countries, as defined by the Global System for Mobile Communications Association mobile connectivity index [21]. In Burkina Faso, a mobile internet-based solution would reach less than 1 of 10 people, while it would reach 3 of 10 people in Côte d’Ivoire and Togo. In these three countries, introducing a non–Web-based solution seems to be the most appropriate intervention. In addition, in a regional context where patients’ fees have been pointed out as a main barrier to access HIV treatment [29,30], our study reported a readiness to pay for better quality health care or at least to support the additional out-of-pocket expenditures generated by the use of their mobile phone to improve the quality of their care, with no significant relationship between financial acceptability and monthly income. Even if our study did not focus on willingness to pay (WTP) as a measure used in the field of health economics, our findings are aligned to the conclusion of a randomized controlled trial carried out in Bangladesh, demonstrating patients’ WTP to benefit from an SMS-based service for managing their type 2 diabetes [31]. In the same country, a previous study already showed patients’ WTP for an improved patient-clinician relationship [32]. However, as there is a scarcity of studies conducted in sub-Saharan Africa in the field of HIV, which target the WTP for digital health services, it seems to be preferable to implement an mHealth solution with a business model that does not increase the user fees, but rather generates benefits to the patients in reducing transportation time, improves waiting time at the clinic, and allows savings on out-of-pocket expenditures.

In our study, participants generally indicated a preference for phone calls, and the acceptability for phone calls was significantly associated with levels of education, such that participants with no education or a primary school level education were more likely to prefer phone calls compared to text messages. This finding of preference for phone calls, and its association with education levels, has been corroborated by other studies in the sub-Saharan region [28,25]. Another study among PLHIV reported that almost all participants indicated their preference for a two-way communication with doctors or nurses, rather than SMS reminders [33]. These findings suggest that mHealth could respond to the need of restoring or strengthening the interface patient-clinician through an improved and personalized relationship. In this way, mHealth could be an appropriate tool to address the issue raised by Tran et al [34] who showed that listening to patients should lead decision makers to improve the quality of health services and decrease the burden of HIV treatment [34]. There is also a need for adaptation of types of communication (text messages or phone calls) to the target PLHIV according to their literacy level. Tailoring text messages interventions to fit with those specific needs of PLHIV is an example of how this adaptation could be implemented. The preference for phone calls could also be explained by several factors including the issue of confidentiality. A qualitative study on PLHIV indicated that although SMS reminders are helpful for treatment adherence, the main concerns are on the delivery mode and the need for confidentiality [35]. This could suggest the importance of using strategies that would protect privacy, ensure confidentiality, and respect human rights for PLHIV.

 Strengths and Limitations

This study was conducted in three countries of West Africa, with a sample of more than 1000 PLHIV from six HIV treatment and care programs, including approximately one-third (34.7%, n=393) who could not read nor write. Findings from this study thus suggest a very good feasibility and acceptability of the use of mHealth in all types of HIV populations. In addition, financial acceptability of mHealth among PLHIV, rarely explored in the literature in West Africa and documented in our study, confer to it an important strength. Furthermore, this study was patient centered, with the involvement of PLHIV from the design and elaboration of the study to the interpretation of the results, as recommended for the design of digital health tool [36]. Most PLHIV organizations of Cote d’Ivoire including the Reseau Ivoirien des organisations de Personnes vivant avec le VIH/Sida (RIP+) and the Coalition des Organisations des Femmes vivant avec le VIH/Sida (COFCI) have been involved in this study since the beginning. In addition, focus groups and interviews were conducted as part of this study among 20 PLHIV and revealed that although messages are highly acceptable, message contents need to be further explored. In fact, PLHIV indicated that contents should be short, highly coded, and customized based on literacy levels.

However, this study has a few limitations. First, it occurred mainly in economic and administrative capitals where mobile network coverage is close to 100% and sharing of mobile phone is limited, even if in these settings, a significant number of people cannot not read or write. If an intervention were to be set up in those cities, further studies would be needed before scaling up to rural and remote areas. Second, only PLHIV already receiving ART were included in the study, of which nearly 70% were stable patients who initiated their treatment over 5 years ago. This could lead to underestimation of the demand for the introduction of an mHealth solution and the willingness to financially contribute, as the targeted population is already adherent and can self-perceive the benefits of the treatment. A bias could have also been introduced with the cross-sectional nature of the study and the fact that recruitment of participants occurred in HIV care and treatment center, systematically including those who are naturally inclined to be retained in care and to adhere to treatment.

Further research, such as qualitative studies, are needed to better understand expectations and perceptions of PLHIV on the contents of text messages or phone calls, especially in terms of confidentiality, privacy, and respect of human rights.

Qualitative studies should also explore health care workers’ perception of the introduction of mHealth into care to assess whether it would be considered a tool to ease their workload or hinder their performance.

Finally, considering that implication of end users is a key factor of success when designing a digital health tool and the need to prevent any potential harm that may result from the use of an mHealth solution in a stigmatizing environment, further qualitative studies shall be conducted in these francophone cities to consider frequency, timing, and content of the SMS in the design of mHealth interventions, as these factors could influence efficacy [36,37].

 Conclusions

Based on a considerable sample size, this study demonstrated that mobile technology is accessible in francophone low-income countries and could be used as a tool to improve the quality of HIV care and treatment. In such a context, mHealth could potentially help francophone West and Central African countries to bridge their treatment gap in the aim to achieve the 90-90-90 goal.

 Abbreviations ART

antiretroviral treatment

 mHealth

mobile health

 PLHIV

People Living with HIV

 SMS

short messages service

 UNAIDS

United Nations Programme on HIV/AIDS

 WHO

World Health Organization

We would like to acknowledge the people living with HIV who participated in this study and networks of PLHIV such as RIP+ and COF-CI who actively contributed.

None declared.

Joint United Nations Programme on HIV/AIDS (UNAIDS) Joint United Nations Programme on HIV/AIDS (UNAIDS) 2017 2018-11-12 Geneva, Switzerland UNAIDS Data 2017https://www.unaids.org/sites/default/files/media_asset/20170720_Data_book_2017_en.pdf Joint United Programme on HIV/AIDS (UNAIDS) 2014 2018-11-19 Geneva, Switzerland Fast-Track: Ending the AIDS epidemic by 2030https://www.unaids.org/sites/default/files/media_asset/JC2686_WAD2014report_en.pdf Samji H Cescon A Hogg RS Modur SP Althoff KN Buchacz K Burchell AN Cohen M Gebo KA Gill MJ Justice A Kirk G Klein MB Korthuis PT Martin J Napravnik S Rourke SB Sterling TR Silverberg MJ Deeks S Jacobson LP Bosch RJ Kitahata MM Goedert JJ Moore R Gange SJ North American AIDS Cohort Collaboration on ResearchDesign (NA-ACCORD) of IeDEA Closing the gap: increases in life expectancy among treated HIV-positive individuals in the United States and Canada PLoS One 2013 12 8 12 e81355 10.1371/journal.pone.0081355 24367482 PONE-D-13-20154 PMC3867319 Teeraananchai S Kerr SJ Amin J Ruxrungtham K Law MG Life expectancy of HIV-positive people after starting combination antiretroviral therapy: a meta-analysis HIV Med 2017 04 18 4 256 266 10.1111/hiv.12421 27578404 World Health Organization (WHO) Consolidated guidelines on the use of antiretroviral drugs for treating and preventing HIV infection: Recommendations for a public health approach 2016 Geneva World Health Organization World Health Organization (WHO) mHealth: New horizons for health through mobile technologies Global observatory for ehealth series (Volume 3) 2011 Geneva World Health Organization Rassi C Gore-Langton GR Gidudu Walimbwa B Strachan CE King R Basharat S Christiansen-Jucht C Graham K Gudoi SS Improving health worker performance through text messaging: A mixed-methods evaluation of a pilot intervention designed to increase coverage of intermittent preventive treatment of malaria in pregnancy in West Nile, Uganda PLoS One 2018 9 13 9 e0203554 10.1371/journal.pone.0203554 30188956 PONE-D-17-42672 PMC6126848 Hirsch-Moverman Y Daftary A Yuengling KA Saito S Ntoane M Frederix K Maama LB Howard AA Using mHealth for HIV/TB Treatment Support in Lesotho JAIDS 2017 74 S37 S43 10.1097/qai.0000000000001202 Jia K Mohamed K Evaluating the use of cell phone messaging for community Ebola syndromic surveillance in high risked settings in Southern Sierra Leone Afr Health Sci 2015 09 15 3 797 802 10.4314/ahs.v15i3.13 26957967 jAFHS.v15.i3.pg797 PMC4765450 Mangam K Fiekowsky E Bagayoko M Norris L Belemvire A Longhany R Fornadel C George K Feasibility and Effectiveness of mHealth for Mobilizing Households for Indoor Residual Spraying to Prevent Malaria: A Case Study in Mali Glob Health Sci Pract 2016 06 27 4 2 222 237 10.9745/ghsp-d-15-00381 Mannik J Figol A Churchill V Aw J Francis S Karino E Chesire JK Opot D Ochieng B Hawkes MT Community-based screening for cardiovascular risk using a novel mHealth tool in rural Kenya J Innov Health Inform 2018 10 31 25 3 176 182 10.14236/jhi.v25i3.1012 30398461 Kingue S Angandji P Menanga AP Ashuntantang G Sobngwi E Dossou-Yovo RA Kaze FF Kengne AP Dzudie A Ndobo P Muna W Efficiency of an intervention package for arterial hypertension comprising telemanagement in a Cameroonian rural setting: The TELEMED-CAM study Pan Afr Med J 2013 15 153 10.11604/pamj.2013.15.153.2655 24396559 PAMJ-15-153 PMC3880813 Ekouevi DK Balestre E Ba-Gomis F Eholie SP Maiga M Amani-Bosse C Minga A Messou E Sow PS Lewden C Traoré HA Bissagnene E Dabis F IeDEA West Africa Collaboration Low retention of HIV-infected patients on antiretroviral therapy in 11 clinical centres in West Africa Trop Med Int Health 2010 06 15 Suppl 1 34 42 10.1111/j.1365-3156.2010.02505.x 20586958 TMI2505 PMC2919326 Plazy M Orne-Gliemann J Dabis F Dray-Spira R Retention in care prior to antiretroviral treatment eligibility in sub-Saharan Africa: a systematic review of the literature BMJ Open 2015 06 24 5 6 e006927 10.1136/bmjopen-2014-006927 26109110 bmjopen-2014-006927 PMC4479994 Kannisto KA Koivunen MH Välimäki MA Use of mobile phone text message reminders in health care services: a narrative literature review J Med Internet Res 2014 10 17 16 10 e222 10.2196/jmir.3442 25326646 v16i11e222 PMC4211035 Mbuagbaw L Thabane L Ongolo-Zogo P Lester RT Mills EJ Smieja M Dolovich L Kouanfack C The Cameroon Mobile Phone SMS (CAMPS) trial: a randomized trial of text messaging versus usual care for adherence to antiretroviral therapy PLoS One 2012 12 7 12 e46909 10.1371/journal.pone.0046909 23236345 PONE-D-12-24092 PMC3516507 Orrell C Cohen K Mauff K Bangsberg DR Maartens G Wood R A Randomized Controlled Trial of Real-Time Electronic Adherence Monitoring With Text Message Dosing Reminders in People Starting First-Line Antiretroviral Therapy JAIDS 2015 70 5 495 502 10.1097/qai.0000000000000770 Joseph Davey D Nhavoto JA Augusto O Ponce W Traca D Nguimfack A Palha de Sousa C SMSaúde: Evaluating mobile phone text message reminders to improve retention in HIV care for patients on antiretroviral therapy JAIDS 2016 73 2 e23 e30 10.1097/qai.0000000000001115 Katz IT Kaplan R Fitzmaurice G Leone D Bangsberg DR Bekker L Orrell C Treatment guidelines and early loss from care for people living with HIV in Cape Town, South Africa: A retrospective cohort study PLoS Med 2017 11 14 11 e1002434 10.1371/journal.pmed.1002434 29136014 PMEDICINE-D-17-02015 PMC5685472 Aranda-Jan CB Mohutsiwa-Dibe N Loukanova S Systematic review on what works, what does not work and why of implementation of mobile health (mHealth) projects in Africa BMC Public Health 2014 02 21 14 188 10.1186/1471-2458-14-188 24555733 1471-2458-14-188 PMC3942265 GSMA 2018 2018-11-02 The mobile connectivity index 2018https://www.gsma.com/mobilefordevelopment/wp-content/uploads/2018/09/GSMA_Mobile-Connectivity-Index-GLOBAL-Fcous.pdf Hall CS Fottrell E Wilkinson S Byass P Assessing the impact of mHealth interventions in low- and middle-income countries--what has been shown to work? Glob Health Action 2014 10 7 25606 10.3402/gha.v7.25606 25361730 25606 PMC4216389 Nachega J Skinner D Jennings L Magidson J Altice F Burke J Lester R Uthman O Knowlton A Cotton M Anderson J Theron G Acceptability and feasibility of mHealth and community-based directly observed antiretroviral therapy to prevent mother-to-child HIV transmission in South African pregnant women under Option B+: an exploratory study PPA 2016 04 683 10.2147/ppa.s100002 Cormick G Ciganda A Cafferata ML Ripple MJ Sosa-Estani S Buekens P Belizán JM Althabe F Text message interventions for follow up of infants born to mothers positive for Chagas disease in Tucumán, Argentina: a feasibility study BMC Res Notes 2015 09 29 8 508 10.1186/s13104-015-1498-9 26419230 10.1186/s13104-015-1498-9 PMC4588257 Kim J Zhang W Nyonyitono M Lourenco L Nanfuka M Okoboi S Birungi J Lester RT Kaleebu P Munderi P Moore DM Feasibility and acceptability of mobile phone short message service as a support for patients receiving antiretroviral therapy in rural Uganda: a cross-sectional study Journal of the International AIDS Society 2015 12 10 18 1 20311 10.7448/ias.18.1.20311 Berry G Smith CL Macaskill P Irwig L Analytic methods for comparing two dichotomous screening or diagnostic tests applied to two populations of differing disease prevalence when individuals negative on both tests are unverified Statist Med 2002 03 30 21 6 853 862 10.1002/sim.1066 Crankshaw T Corless IB Giddy J Nicholas PK Eichbaum Q Butler LM Exploring the patterns of use and the feasibility of using cellular phones for clinic appointment reminders and adherence messages in an antiretroviral treatment clinic, Durban, South Africa AIDS Patient Care STDS 2010 11 24 11 729 34 10.1089/apc.2010.0146 21039181 Kinyua F Kiptoo M Kikuvi G Mutai J Meyers AFA Muiruri P Songok E Perceptions of HIV infected patients on the use of cell phone as a tool to support their antiretroviral adherence; a cross-sectional study in a large referral hospital in Kenya BMC Public Health 2013 10 21 13 987 10.1186/1471-2458-13-987 24143931 1471-2458-13-987 PMC4016520 Le prix de l'oubli Médecins Sans Frontières 2016 Bruxelles, Belgique Médecins sans frontières The Western and Central Africa Catch-up plan: Putting HIV treatment on the fast-track by 2018 Joint United Nations Programme on HIV/AIDS (UNAIDS) 2018 Geneva UNAIDS Shariful Islam SM Lechner A Ferrari U Seissler J Holle R Niessen LW Mobile phone use and willingness to pay for SMS for diabetes in Bangladesh J Public Health (Oxf) 2016 03 38 1 163 9 10.1093/pubmed/fdv009 25687131 fdv009 Pavel MS Chakrabarty S Gow J Assessing willingness to pay for health care quality improvements BMC Health Serv Res 2015 02 01 15 43 10.1186/s12913-015-0678-6 25638204 s12913-015-0678-6 PMC4332931 Georgette N Siedner MJ Zanoni B Sibaya T Petty CR Carpenter S Haberer JE The Acceptability and Perceived Usefulness of a Weekly Clinical SMS Program to Promote HIV Antiretroviral Medication Adherence in KwaZulu-Natal, South Africa AIDS Behav 2016 11 20 11 2629 2638 10.1007/s10461-016-1287-z 26781866 10.1007/s10461-016-1287-z PMC4949151 Tran V Messou E Mama Djima M Ravaud P Ekouevi DK Patients' perspectives on how to decrease the burden of treatment: a qualitative study of HIV care in sub-Saharan Africa BMJ Qual Saf 2019 04 28 4 266 275 10.1136/bmjqs-2017-007564 29706594 bmjqs-2017-007564 Sherman E Clauson KA Elrod S Eckardt P Alkhateeb F Jacobs R Patient Perceptions of Text Messaging to Improve Antiretroviral Therapy Adherence: A Qualitative Study of Patients in a Ryan White Clinic J Int Assoc Provid AIDS Care 2018 02 17 2325958218759209 10.1177/2325958218759209 29473483 Birnbaum F Lewis D Rosen RK Ranney ML Patient engagement and the design of digital health Acad Emerg Med 2015 06 22 6 754 6 10.1111/acem.12692 25997375 PMC4674428 Finitsis DJ Pellowski JA Johnson BT Text message intervention designs to promote adherence to antiretroviral therapy (ART): a meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials PLoS One 2014 2 9 2 e88166 10.1371/journal.pone.0088166 24505411 PONE-D-13-33524 PMC3914915