Published on 02.10.17 in Vol 5, No 10 (2017): October
Preprints (earlier versions) of this paper are available at http://preprints.jmir.org/preprint/7058, first published Nov 28, 2016.
Impact of a Telehealth Program With Voice Recognition Technology in Patients With Chronic Heart Failure: Feasibility Study
Background: Despite the advances in the diagnosis and treatment of heart failure (HF), the current hospital-oriented framework for HF management does not appear to be sufficient to maintain the stability of HF patients in the long term. The importance of self-care management is increasingly being emphasized as a promising long-term treatment strategy for patients with chronic HF.
Objective: The objective of this study was to evaluate whether a new information communication technology (ICT)–based telehealth program with voice recognition technology could improve clinical or laboratory outcomes in HF patients.
Methods: In this prospective single-arm pilot study, we recruited 31 consecutive patients with chronic HF who were referred to our institute. An ICT-based telehealth program with voice recognition technology was developed and used by patients with HF for 12 weeks. Patients were educated on the use of this program via mobile phone, landline, or the Internet for the purpose of improving communication and data collection. Using these systems, we collected comprehensive data elements related to the risk of HF self-care management such as weight, diet, exercise, medication adherence, overall symptom change, and home blood pressure. The study endpoints were the changes observed in urine sodium concentration (uNa), Minnesota Living with Heart Failure (MLHFQ) scores, 6-min walk test, and N-terminal prohormone of brain natriuretic peptide (NT-proBNP) as surrogate markers for appropriate HF management.
Results: Among the 31 enrolled patients, 27 (87%) patients completed the study, and 10 (10/27, 37%) showed good adherence to ICT-based telehealth program with voice recognition technology, which was defined as the use of the program for 100 times or more during the study period. Nearly three-fourths of the patients had been hospitalized at least once because of HF before the enrollment (20/27, 74%); 14 patients had 1, 2 patients had 2, and 4 patients had 3 or more previous HF hospitalizations. In the total study population, there was no significant interval change in laboratory and functional outcome variables after 12 weeks of ICT-based telehealth program. In patients with good adherence to ICT-based telehealth program, there was a significant improvement in the mean uNa (103.1 to 78.1; P=.01) but not in those without (85.4 to 96.9; P=.49). Similarly, a marginal improvement in MLHFQ scores was only observed in patients with good adherence (27.5 to 21.4; P=.08) but not in their counterparts (19.0 to 19.7; P=.73). The mean 6-min walk distance and NT-proBNP were not significantly increased in patients regardless of their adherence.
Conclusions: Short-term application of ICT-based telehealth program with voice recognition technology showed the potential to improve uNa values and MLHFQ scores in HF patients, suggesting that better control of sodium intake and greater quality of life can be achieved by this program.
JMIR Mhealth Uhealth 2017;5(10):e127
Heart failure (HF) is a major public health issue, with a prevalence of over 23 million worldwide and rising with the aging of the population [, ]. The characteristic feature of HF is a progressive loss of cardiomyocytes and the development of cardiac dysfunction, ultimately leading to frequent hospitalization and significant morbidity and mortality [ , - ]. There are ongoing efforts to develop improved therapeutic and preventive strategies for HF, as most current strategies fail to reduce readmission rates and maintain the stability of HF patients in the long term [ , ].
Most hospitalizations for acute decompensated HF are attributable to poor self-care, including lack of knowledge, nonadherence to proper diet or medications, and failure of self-management of symptoms. Recent studies on patient-centered out-of-hospital management of HF patients have shown improvements in prognosis and quality of life [, - ]. However, in practice, barriers to self-care management such as insufficient personalized real-time feedback to patients regarding body weight, fluid balance, and physical activity limit their effectiveness [ , , ]. Frequent assessment of physiologic parameters related to HF aggravation and remote disease management aided by advances in telemonitoring systems based on information communication technology (ICT) may be an approach to overcome the limitations of self-management. By enabling early detection of HF decompensation and through timely intervention, it may be possible to achieve improved outcomes and reduced medical costs for HF patients [ , ].
Voice recognition technology enables the recognition and translation of verbal information into text, which can then be used in automated data processing systems. With advances in the accuracy of this technology, it is being applied in the medical field to facilitate interest and improve the adherence of patients with chronic conditions such as asthma, diabetes mellitus, and glaucoma [- ]. In a recent study, an ICT-based telehealth program with voice recognition technology was effective in achieving glycemic control without hypoglycemia in elderly diabetic patients [ ]. Given that voice recognition technology can facilitate the gathering of data that are currently difficult to retrieve, as it enables patients, particularly the elderly, to easily access the system and input their data and does not entail additional equipment costs to collect the necessary data, an ICT-based telehealth program incorporating this technology may be a promising tool for improving clinical or laboratory outcomes in chronic HF patients. However, data regarding the role of this novel suite of technologies in the self-management of HF patients are scarce.
With the expectation of enhanced interactivity and active engagement of participants and delivery of tailored interventions, ultimately leading to effective self-care of HF, we developed an ICT-based telehealth program featuring voice recognition technology for HF and sought to explore whether this new program influences the control of sodium intake and quality of life in patients with chronic HF.
Study Design and Population
This study was designed as a prospective single-arm pilot study. The study sample was recruited from consecutive HF patients who were referred to the outpatient clinic of our institute since July 2014. Inclusion criteria were as follows: (1) age ≥18 years; (2) left ventricular (LV) systolic HF diagnosis for >3 months, regardless of etiology according to current guidelines [, ]; (3) LV ejection fraction (EF) <40% on transthoracic echocardiography of a duration of at least 3 months; (4) New York Heart Association (NYHA) class II or III; and (5) clinical stability including no change in medications for at least the past 4 weeks. Exclusion criteria were the following: (1) hospitalization within 3 months or a condition expected to require hospitalization; (2) a history of acute myocardial infarction or unstable angina within 6 months; (3) a history of significant valvular heart disease requiring surgical or interventional correction; (4) renal replacement therapy; (5) severe hepatic dysfunction defined as aspartate transaminase and alanine transaminase ≥3 times the upper normal limits; (6) malignancy with life expectancy <6 months; (7) childbearing potential or breastfeeding; (8) functional impairment related to severe musculoskeletal or neurological problems; and (9) refusal to participate. The study protocol was in accordance with the Declaration of Helsinki and approved by the institutional review board of our institution. Written informed consent was obtained from all the enrolled subjects.
Patients were educated regarding the full range of HF self-care behaviors, including diet, exercise, and medication adherence. All participants underwent the following assessments at baseline and after 12 weeks of the ICT-based telehealth program: medical history, physical examination, laboratory tests including urine sodium concentration (uNa) and N-terminal prohormone of brain natriuretic peptide (NT-proBNP), 6-min walk test, NYHA functional class, and Minnesota Living with Heart Failure Questionnaire (MLHFQ) scores [- ]. The study endpoints included the changes in uNa, MLHFQ scores, NT-proBNP, and 6-min walk distance after 12 weeks of intervention. The adherence to the telehealth program was also analyzed, and a good adherence was defined as the use of the program for 100 times or more during the 12-week intervention period. The study flow is illustrated in .
The ICT-Based Telehealth Program
The ICT-based telehealth center comprised multidisciplinary team members, including experienced cardiologists, professional nurses, a dietitian, and computer programmers. Participants were instructed to use the ICT-based telehealth program with voice recognition technology (AIMMED Co Ltd) that was developed for HF patients to provide data and to communicate with clinicians more conveniently through ordinary communication channels via their handheld mobile phone or landline. Patients used their voice or touch-tone telephone keypads to enter essential information for the assessment of HF, including daily weight, diet, exercise, medication adherence, overall symptom change, and home blood pressure.illustrates the schematic diagram of the ICT-based telehealth program.
Direct voice input of health-related data was performed via landline or mobile phone through the automatic call and response system. The automatic call system was programmed to automatically dial the participants’ registered phone numbers once daily 5 days per week for 12 weeks, and when a person answered the phone, it asked prespecified questions to collect narrative responses. Additionally, patients were also allowed free calls into the system during the study period to collect health-related data from participants who did not answer the call from the automatic call system. Patients, guided by a series of prespecified verbal questions, were requested to speak or to enter a preset range of inputs, including body weight, blood pressure, heart rate, and HF-related symptoms. Examples of possible answers were also presented for patients’ convenience and to reduce the error of the data collection. To further ensure the accuracy of data, the program provided patients the opportunity to either confirm or correct the initial extracted data. An example flow diagram for voice recognition is shown in.
A clinical decision support system was implemented to provide immediate tailored feedback by voice or text messages (short message service, SMS) to patients according to a predetermined algorithm following current guidelines [, ]. When data entries were outside predefined ranges or symptoms were reported, an automatic phone call was made to patients to confirm the data and to their attending physicians and research nurses to notify them of the occurrence of these events. Patients received timely self-care feedback from their physicians and were monitored to ensure resolution. Attending physicians were able to tailor HF management and adjust clinic visit schedules, taking into account the clinical status of each patient. After an out-of-range value occurred, the choice of whether to modify the limits of the range was at the discretion of the physician, who made the decision weighing the individual risk and benefit. Patients were instructed on the use of the website or mobile app created for this study, which provided individually tailored feedback messages based on data entered by the patients ( ). By analyzing the cumulative data of each individual, patients also received personalized guidance on long-term self-care management of HF via the website or as a mobile report. We summarized the functionalities of the ICT-based telehealth program used in our study compared with previous programs in .
Venous blood and urinary samples were obtained from all patients at baseline and after completion of 12 weeks of ICT-based telehealth program. Data including uNa, NT-proBNP, 6-min walk test, and MLHFQ scores were collected to assess the impact of this program on patient outcomes. Specifically, uNa and NT-proBNP were used to assess the adherence to a low-salt diet and the progression of HF, respectively. To assess functional capacity, 6-min walk test was conducted using a standardized protocol between 11 AM to 2 PM on usual medications [, ]. Briefly, patients were required to perform a 6-min shuttle walk test with markers placed every 25 m. During the 6-min walk test, patients were accompanied by trained research nurses, who were independent of this study, for the safety of participants as well as for the accuracy and reliability of the results. We also used MLHFQ scores to quantify and compare health-related quality of life outcomes before and after the telehealth program [ - ]. The MLHFQ is an established questionnaire, which was developed to measure the subjective influence of HF and HF treatments on an individual’s quality of life, including physical, socioeconomic, and emotional aspects. It comprises 21 items with scores ranging from 0 to 105, and higher scores indicate a lower quality of life in HF patients [ , ].
Descriptive statistics were used to characterize the study population and measurements. Data were presented as numbers and percentages for categorical variables and mean ± standard error for continuous variables. Differences between continuous variables were compared by the Student t test or Mann-Whitney U test for independent samples, and those between categorical variables were analyzed by the chi-square test or Fisher exact test, as appropriate. A P value of <.05 was considered statistically significant. The Wilcoxon signed-rank test was used to compare values before and after ICT-based telehealth program. In addition, subgroup analysis was also performed according to the adherence to intervention.
Baseline Characteristics of Study Population
Of the 40 chronic HF patients who were screened, 31 subjects met the inclusion and exclusion criteria and agreed to participate in this study. Furthermore, 4 patients (4/31, 13%) were dropped from the study because of hospitalization for acute decompensated HF (n=2) and withdrawal of consent (n=2). Two patients hospitalized for acute decompensated HF withdrew within 1 week and 4 weeks of starting the study, respectively, and the cause of HF hospitalization was considered to be a viral infection in both patients. The final analysis was performed in 27 patients (27/31, 87%) who completed the baseline and 12-week measurements. Ten patients (10/27, 37%) showed good adherence to the program, defined as the frequency of its use ≥100 times during the 12-week intervention period.describes the baseline characteristics of the total study population and subgroups according to adherence to the intervention. The mean age of the total study population was 63.4 years, and one-third were females (9/27, 33%). Nearly three-fourths had been hospitalized at least once because of HF before the enrollment (20/27, 74%). The number of prior HF hospitalizations per individual was 1.15; 14 patients had 1, 2 patients had 2, and 4 patients had 3 or more previous HF hospitalizations. Before the program started, 70% of patients were already undergoing treatment with diuretics, including mineralocorticoid receptor antagonists (19/27, 70%). There were no changes in HF medications or dosages during the study period. The etiology of 8 patients was ischemia. The baseline mean values of LV ejection fraction, MLHFQ scores, and 6-min walk distance were 30%, 22.2 points, and 408.4 m, respectively. When comparing the baseline characteristics between patients according to adherence to the program, there was no significant difference between the groups. Patients with good adherence tended to have worse baseline parameters, including significantly more frequent hospitalizations related to HF, greater levels of NT-proBNP and uNa, higher MLHFQ scores, and shorter 6-min walk distances, compared with those without ( ).
Approach and Satisfaction of ICT-Based Telehealth Program
Twenty-one patients utilized the program via their mobile phone or landline, and about 59% (16/27) of them also accessed the website. The accuracy of voice recognition was 93% and 95% in patients using mobile phone and landline, respectively. Of the patients in whom the user experience with the voice recognition system could be evaluated, ≥85% patients (23/27) indicated that they were satisfied or neutral with the service provided, as shown in. Patients were interested in the following services: blood pressure (27/27, 100%), followed by body weight (26/27, 96%; 951 cases/week), and medication (26/27, 96%; 776 cases/week). shows the utilization according to the method and the components accessed.
|Characteristics||All patients |
|Patients with good adherence (n=10)||Patients without good adherence (n=17)||P values|
|Age in years, mean ± SEa||63.4 ± 1.8||62.1 ± 2.7||64.1 ± 2.4||.60|
|Female gender, n (%)||9 (33)||2 (20)||7 (41)||.41|
|Height in cm, mean ± SE||161.4 ± 1.4||164.7 ± 1.9||159.4 ± 1.8||.07|
|Weight in kg, mean ± SE||63.7 ± 1.9||64.8 ± 2.8||63.1 ± 2.7||.70|
|Body mass index in kg/m2, mean ± SE||24.4 ± 0.6||23.9 ± 0.4||24.7 ± 0.6||.52|
|Clinical history, n (%)|
|Hypertension||12 (44)||4 (40)||8 (47)||.72|
|Diabetes mellitus||6 (22)||3 (30)||3 (18)||.46|
|Atrial fibrillation||11 (41)||4 (40)||7 (41)||.95|
|Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease||1 (4)||1 (10)||0 (0)||.18|
|Chronic kidney disease||10 (37)||4 (40)||6 (35)||.81|
|Prior myocardial infarction||9 (33)||5 (51)||4 (24)||.16|
|Prior hospitalization due to HFb||20 (74)||6 (60)||14 (82)||.20|
|Signs and symptoms on enrollment, mean ± SE|
|Systolic BPc, mm Hg||117.3 ± 2.5||116.1 ± 4.3||117.9 ± 3.1||.73|
|Diastolic BP, mm Hg||68.4 ± 1.3||68.5 ± 1.4||68.4 ± 1.9||.98|
|Heart rate, beats per minute||67.9 ± 2.3||64.4 ± 4.0||69.9 ± 2.8||.26|
|Medications on enrollment, n (%)|
|Diuretics||19 (70)||6 (60)||13 (77)||.42|
|ACEId||9 (33)||4 (40)||4 (29)||.68|
|ARBe||15 (56)||4 (40)||11 (65)||.26|
|Beta blocker||12 (44)||4 (40)||8 (47)||>.99|
|Calcium channel blocker||4 (15)||1 (10)||3 (18)||>.99|
|Spironolactone||19 (70)||7 (70)||12 (71)||>.99|
|Digoxin||8 (30)||3 (30)||5 (29)||>.99|
|Etiology, n (%)|
|Ischemic||8 (30)||4 (40)||4 (29)||.37|
|Nonischemic||19 (70)||6 (60)||13 (77)||.42|
|Laboratory variables, mean ± SE|
|WBCf, × 103/uL||6.4 ± 0.3||6.1 ± 0.5||6.6 ± 0.3||.37|
|Hemoglobin, g/dL||13.4 ± 0.3||13.6 ± 0.5||13.3 ± 0.4||.60|
|Platelet, × 103/uL||196.7 ± 9.5||178.6 ± 14.3||207.3 ± 12.0||.15|
|Sodium, mmol/L||139.6 ± 0.5||140.2 ± 0.7||139.2 ± 0.6||.35|
|Potassium, mmol/L||4.6 ± 0.1||4.7 ± 0.2||4.5 ± 0.1||.27|
|Chloride, mmol/L||102.9 ± 0.6||104.6 ± 0.8||101.9 ± 0.8||.13|
|Total CO2g, mmol/L||28.5 ± 0.6||27.2 ± 1.2||29.2 ± 0.7||.13|
|Calcium, mg/dL||9.4 ± 0.1||9.2 ± 0.2||9.5 ± 0.1||.13|
|Phosphate, mg/dL||3.6 ± 0.1||3.5 ± 0.1||3.8 ± 0.1||.13|
|Blood urea nitrogen, mg/dL||18.2 ± 1.3||17.7 ± 2.5||18.5 ± 1.5||.78|
|Creatinine, mg/dL||1.1 ± 0.1||1.2 ± 0.3||1.0 ± 0.1||.35|
|GFRh, mL/min/1.73 m2||69.8 ± 3.6||70.6 ± 7.7||69.3 ± 3.8||.88|
|NT-proBNPi, pg/mL||288.6 ± 65.7||300.2 ± 108.1||281.7 ± 85.2||.90|
|Urine sodium, mmol/L||91.9 ± 0.5||103.1 ± 9.2||85.4 ± 10.5||.26|
|LVj ejection fraction, %||30.3 ± 1.3||30.7 ± 2.4||30.1 ± 1.5||.81|
|Quality of life data, mean ± SE||MLHFQk score||22.2 ± 3.2||27.5 ± 6.4||19.0 ± 3.3||.20|
|Functional status data, mean ± SE||6-min walk distance, m||408.4 ± 16.1||404.0 ± 30.1||411.0 ± 19.2||.84|
aSE: standard error.
bHF: heart failure.
cBP: blood pressure.
dACEI: angiotensin-converting enzyme inhibitor.
eARB: angiotensin receptor blocker.
fWBC: white blood cell.
gCO2: carbon dioxide.
hGFR: glomerular filtration rate.
iNT-proBNP: N-terminal prohormone of brain natriuretic peptide.
jLV: left ventricular.
kMLHFQ: Minnesota Living with Heart Failure Questionnaire.
|Data on utilization||Patients accessed, n (%)||Frequency of access per week|
|Type of access method|
|Mobile phone or landline||21 (77.8)||2297|
|Website access||16 (59.3)||433|
|Type of accessed component|
|Body weight||26 (96.3)||951|
|Overall symptom change||22 (81.5)||651|
|Blood pressure||27 (100.0)||2812|
aACS: automatic call system.
bARS: automatic response system.
cTTS: text to speech.
Changes After Using ICT-Based Telehealth Program
In the total study population, there was no significant interval change in laboratory and functional outcome variables after 12 weeks of ICT-based telehealth program (): uNa (91.9 to 90.0; P=.45), MLHFQ scores (22.2 to 20.3; P=.18), 6-min walk distance, (408.4 to 410.6; P=.59), and NT-proBNP (288.6 to 318.1; P=.91). When we stratified patients into two groups by adherence to the ICT-based telehealth program, there was a significant reduction in the value of uNa (103.1 to 78.1; P=.01) and a marginal decrease in the MLHFQ scores (27.5 to 21.4; P=.08) in HF patients with good adherence ( ). However, no significant changes were observed in those without good adherence regarding these variables ( ). On the other hand, 6-min walk distance neither significantly improved in patients with good adherence nor in those without ( ). No significant change in NT-proBNP was observed in both groups of patients ( and ). The MLHFQ scores decreased after 12 weeks of ICT-based telehealth program in 18 patients (18/27, 67%). When we assessed the change in the subscores of physical (8 items), emotional (5 items), and socioeconomic (8 items) dimensions of the MLHFQ, although statistically insignificant, patients with good adherence showed numerically greater improvements in all dimensions. Specifically, the improvement in the total score of MLHFQ was largely driven by the decrease in emotional dimension measures among three quality of life dimensions (94%, 17/18 patients). The change in emotional domain scores was −2.1 in patients with good adherence and −0.2 in those without (P=.48). Results in terms of physical dimension measures revealed that the change was −2.5 in patients with good adherence and 0.35 in those without (P=.13). Regarding socioeconomic dimension measures, the change was −1.5 in patients with good adherence and 0.5 in those without (P=.11).
This study is a prospective pilot study examining the possibility of ICT-based telehealth program with voice recognition technology in HF and building up the foundation for further large-scale randomized controlled studies. Our study demonstrated that chronic HF patients with good adherence to ICT-based telehealth program showed improvement in uNa and in symptoms evaluated by the MLHFQ scores. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first study to implement this novel technology to improve self-care of HF. Our study may pave the way for further large-scale clinical outcome trials to determine the efficacy and feasibility of ICT-based interventions for long-term management of HF patients.
Impact of ICT-Based Telehealth Program in HF on Urine Sodium Concentration
The key characteristics of HF include an increase in sodium avidity and a tendency toward congestion [, ]. Therefore, the maintenance of sodium and water balance is a critical element of HF management, and among several noninvasive methods proposed to assess this balance, uNa has been increasingly used as a simple, inexpensive, and noninvasive indicator for the dietary sodium intake [ - ]. Specifically, it is well established that the urinary sodium excretion is precisely regulated to match dietary sodium intake [ , ]. Although the assessment of 24-hour urine sodium excretion is considered the gold standard method, the measurement of spot uNa could provide an approximate estimate of sodium excretion, with increased convenience and low cost [ , , - ]. On the other hand, a previous study demonstrated that spot uNa was reduced by decongestive therapy for advanced HF, which might provide insightful information to titrate the diuretic dose [ , ]. Hence, in general, decreased uNa in HF patients can be a result of low salt intake or effective diuretic therapy [ ]. In this study, HF patients with good adherence to ICT-based telehealth program showed reduced uNa after 12 weeks of intervention. Given that patients were clinically stable without any evidence of acute destabilized HF and change in diuretic dose, decreased uNa might be a reflection of better control of dietary salt intake. As recent data emphasize nonpharmacological as well as pharmacological interventions for HF because of its progressive nature [ ], an ICT-based telehealth program can be a useful tool for improving self-care and, potentially, prognosis in HF patients [ ].
Impact of ICT-Based Telehealth Program in HF on the MLHFQ Scores
Improving health-related quality of life is not only a major treatment goal in HF but also an effective surrogate marker of appropriate HF therapy and improved prognosis in HF patients [, - ]. Among various methods of assessing health-related quality of life, we used the MLHFQ, which has been extensively validated in HF patients [ , , , , ]. In our study, the mean MLHFQ scores numerically decreased by about 2 points in all patients (P=.18) and by 6.1 points in patients with good adherence (P=.08) after 12 weeks of ICT-based telehealth program. Although there is no absolute cutoff for the MLHFQ scores to discriminate between normal and impaired quality of life, a decrease of more than 5 points is considered as a clinically important change [ , ]. Previous studies have suggested that the changes in the MLHFQ scores can translate into differences in clinical outcomes of HF patients. For example, EPICAL trial showed that a 10-point decrement in the MLHFQ scores was associated with a 23% decrease in mortality and a 31% decrease in readmission for HF [ ]. Hoekstra et al [ ] also reported that each 10-point increment in the MLHFQ scores was associated with a 7% increase in mortality. Given that the short duration of intervention in this study led to a 6.1 point decrease in the MLHFQ scores among patients with good adherence, an ICT-based telehealth program seems promising to enhance quality of life and consequently survival of HF patients. Since the MLHFQ comprises three subscores (physical, emotional, and socioeconomic dimensions), we also compared the changes in each of the subscores between groups. In this analysis, the reduction in the MLHFQ scores mostly stemmed from the improvement in emotional aspects in patients with good adherence, although the between-group difference was not significant. These findings suggest that intense monitoring and automated feedback using an ICT-based telehealth program can play a pivotal role in providing emotional support for HF patients. Considering the close relationship between emotional health and hard clinical outcomes in HF [ , ], ICT-based telehealth program has the potential to improve the prognosis of HF patients. The improvement in physical subscores was also numerically greater in patients with good adherence without reaching statistical significance. Considering that patients with good adherence to ICT-based telehealth program showed reduced uNa, a surrogate marker of better control of sodium intake, it seems plausible that this program can also be helpful in improving the physical aspects of quality of life in HF patients. A future study with a large sample size is needed to validate these findings.
Importance of Adherence in Self-Care Management
Previous studies demonstrated that self-care management using telemonitoring systems did not significantly improve hard endpoints in HF patients, such as all-cause death or HF hospitalization [, ]. The low rate of adherence to self-care management programs has been suggested as one of possible reasons for these suboptimal results. In the tele-HF trial, only 55% of study patients utilized the telemonitoring system at least 3 times per week during 6 months and, furthermore, 14% of patients never used this system during the study period [ ]. In our study, 23 of 27 patients (85.2%) utilized ICT-based telehealth program at least 3 times per week during 12 weeks, and there were no patients who did not use the program. Furthermore, 10 of 27 patients (37.0%) used the ICT-based telehealth program ≥100 times during the 12-week period, indicating the use of this program more than once daily. These patients with good adherence to the program showed the improvement in sodium intake and quality of life. This improved adherence of patients may be partially due to the enhanced integration of ICT-based telehealth program into their daily lives, with the easier use of such systems.
User Experience With Voice Recognition Component of the Technology
The user experience was positive with ≥85% patients indicating satisfaction or neutral response with the voice recognition system provided. This favorable user experience might have been achieved by the acceptable success rate of voice recognition in our study, considering that 95% accuracy is nearly on par with that of human speech recognition. In this study, however, the accuracy of voice recognition was affected by adverse conditions, including the use of nonstandard speech, voice alteration during walking, and the presence of substantial background noise. Specifically, the success rate of voice recognition was 91% and 86% for the patients who used nonstandard language and for those who were walking during the process of voice recognition, respectively. Furthermore, the success rate was 87% in settings with increased background noise level, such as when using public transportation. Hence, the user experience can be further optimized by improving the accuracy of voice recognition under these unfavorable circumstances.
Implications of Using ICT-Based Telehealth Program With Voice Recognition Technology on Study Endpoints
HF patients performing and maintaining self-care management behaviors, such as control of sodium intake (uNa), is one practical implication of this technology from a health care perspective. Although future studies with larger number of HF patients are warranted, this technology also has the potential to improve health-related quality of life (MLHFQ scores). Current implications for improving functional capacity (6-min walk test) or HF severity (NT-proBNP) are limited. Further studies are also needed to determine whether the use of this technology has workforce implications in the management of HF patients.
This study has several limitations that should be considered. First, our sample size was small and the duration of intervention was short. This limitation made it difficult to show the benefit of the ICT-based telehealth program for clinical outcomes in HF patients, especially given the chronic and progressive nature of HF. However, in the case of pilot studies, sample sizes of 10 to 30 are generally considered large enough to test the null hypothesis and small enough to ignore weak treatment effects . Furthermore, even though our study population largely comprised patients with moderate to severe systolic dysfunction (LVEF <40%) whose mortality is substantial (25.6%-41.7%) [ ], there was no mortality and only 2 patients withdrew because of hospitalization for acute decompensated HF at the early phase of the study. Notably, the most likely cause of HF exacerbation in these patients was viral infection, not a high-salt diet or poor adherence to medication. In addition, there were no rehospitalizations or emergency department visits for HF after 4 weeks of intervention in our study participants, approximately 75% of whom had a history of prior HF hospitalizations, suggesting that clinical outcomes can be improved by applying this strategy to HF patients. Considering that a prior history of HF hospitalizations has been reported as a risk factor for repeat hospitalizations in HF patients [ , ], our findings suggest that clinical outcomes can be improved by the appropriate application of ICT-based telehealth program in HF patients, although larger studies with longer follow-up are definitely warranted. Second, the definition of good adherence was arbitrary. We assumed that the total frequency of program use of more than 100 times during the follow-up of 12 weeks could be regarded as accessing the system at least once per day. Third, we did not have data on baseline education level, including literacy, health care literacy, digital literacy, and numeracy skills of the study population, which can be critical components for successful technology uptake [ ]. Fourth, although spot uNa provides an approximate estimate of sodium excretion, it has limited usefulness as an indicator of long-term dietary behavior change because of its short-term relevance. Thus, a future study using a more accurate surrogate marker, such as 24-hour urine sodium excretion, is warranted to more clearly discern the beneficial effect of ICT-based telehealth program on sodium intake. Finally, because of the lack of an appropriate control arm, study findings should be interpreted with caution. A prospective randomized study comparing an ICT-based telehealth program with conventional HF care is necessary to define the true clinical benefit from this therapeutic strategy in HF patients.
Short-term application of ICT-based telehealth program in HF demonstrated the potential to improve control of sodium intake and quality of life in chronic HF patients with good adherence to this program. Our results suggest that an ICT-based telehealth program can be an effective strategy to achieve better patient care and clinical outcomes in HF.
This study was partly supported by a grant from the Ministry of Science, ICT and Future Planning, Republic of Korea (F1101-13-1010).
Conflicts of Interest
Jong-Hyuk Choi and Young-Joon Lee hold a patent of invention for voice recognition technology applied to HF self-care management (Korea patent number 10-1141605). They are also employees and shareholders of AIMMED Co Ltd, which provides this ICT service. Other authors report no conflicts of interest to disclose.
Multimedia Appendix 1
The ICT-based telehealth program website.PDF File (Adobe PDF File), 182KB
Multimedia Appendix 2
Comparison of characteristics of ICT-based telehealth program with voice recognition technology and previous programs.PDF File (Adobe PDF File), 27KB
Multimedia Appendix 3
Patient satisfaction with the voice recognition component of the technology.PDF File (Adobe PDF File), 261KB
- Mozaffarian D, Benjamin EJ, Go AS, Arnett DK, Blaha MJ, Cushman M, et al. Heart disease and stroke statistics--2015 update: a report from the American Heart Association. Circulation 2015 Jan 27;131(4):e29-322. [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Ho KK, Pinsky JL, Kannel WB, Levy D. The epidemiology of heart failure: the Framingham Study. J Am Coll Cardiol 1993 Oct;22(4 Suppl A):6A-13A. [Medline]
- Yancy CW, Jessup M, Bozkurt B, Butler J, Casey DE, Drazner MH, American College of Cardiology Foundation, American Heart Association Task Force on Practice Guidelines. 2013 ACCF/AHA guideline for the management of heart failure: a report of the American College of Cardiology Foundation/American Heart Association Task Force on Practice Guidelines. J Am Coll Cardiol 2013 Oct 15;62(16):e147-e239 [FREE Full text] [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Setoguchi S, Stevenson LW, Schneeweiss S. Repeated hospitalizations predict mortality in the community population with heart failure. Am Heart J 2007 Aug;154(2):260-266. [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Goodlin SJ. Palliative care in congestive heart failure. J Am Coll Cardiol 2009 Jul 28;54(5):386-396 [FREE Full text] [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Kociol RD, Peterson ED, Hammill BG, Flynn KE, Heidenreich PA, Piña IL, et al. National survey of hospital strategies to reduce heart failure readmissions: findings from the get With the guidelines-heart failure registry. Circ Heart Fail 2012 Nov;5(6):680-687 [FREE Full text] [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Gheorghiade M, Vaduganathan M, Fonarow GC, Bonow RO. Rehospitalization for heart failure: problems and perspectives. J Am Coll Cardiol 2013 Jan 29;61(4):391-403 [FREE Full text] [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Currie K, Strachan PH, Spaling M, Harkness K, Barber D, Clark AM. The importance of interactions between patients and healthcare professionals for heart failure self-care: a systematic review of qualitative research into patient perspectives. Eur J Cardiovasc Nurs 2015 Dec;14(6):525-535. [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Ponikowski P, Voors AA, Anker SD, Bueno H, Cleland JGF, Coats AJS, et al. 2016 ESC guidelines for the diagnosis and treatment of acute and chronic heart failure: the task force for the diagnosis and treatment of acute and chronic heart failure of the European society of cardiology (ESC) developed with the special contribution of the heart failure association (HFA) of the ESC. Eur Heart J 2016 Jul 14;37(27):2129-2200. [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Lainscak M, Blue L, Clark AL, Dahlström U, Dickstein K, Ekman I, et al. Self-care management of heart failure: practical recommendations from the patient care committee of the heart failure association of the European society of cardiology. Eur J Heart Fail 2011 Feb;13(2):115-126. [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Mead H, Andres E, Ramos C, Siegel B, Regenstein M. Barriers to effective self-management in cardiac patients: the patient's experience. Patient Educ Couns 2010 Apr;79(1):69-76. [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Inglis SC, Clark RA, McAlister FA, Stewart S, Cleland JGF. Which components of heart failure programmes are effective? a systematic review and meta-analysis of the outcomes of structured telephone support or telemonitoring as the primary component of chronic heart failure management in 8323 patients: abridged cochrane review. Eur J Heart Fail 2011 Sep;13(9):1028-1040. [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Jerant AF, Azari R, Nesbitt TS. Reducing the cost of frequent hospital admissions for congestive heart failure: a randomized trial of a home telecare intervention. Med Care 2001 Nov;39(11):1234-1245. [Medline]
- Adams WG, Fuhlbrigge AL, Miller CW, Panek CG, Gi Y, Loane KC, et al. TLC-Asthma: an integrated information system for patient-centered monitoring, case management, and point-of-care decision support. AMIA Annu Symp Proc 2003:1-5 [FREE Full text] [Medline]
- Kim KM, Park KS, Lee HJ, Lee YH, Bae JS, Lee YJ, et al. Efficacy of a new medical information system, ubiquitous healthcare service with voice inception technique in elderly diabetic patients. Sci Rep 2015 Dec 11;5:18214 [FREE Full text] [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Glanz K, Beck AD, Bundy L, Primo S, Lynn MJ, Cleveland J, et al. Impact of a health communication intervention to improve glaucoma treatment adherence. Results of the interactive study to increase glaucoma adherence to treatment trial. Arch Ophthalmol 2012 Oct;130(10):1252-1258 [FREE Full text] [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Alla F, Briançon S, Guillemin F, Juillière Y, Mertès P, Villemot J, et al. Self-rating of quality of life provides additional prognostic information in heart failure. Insights into the EPICAL study. Eur J Heart Fail 2002 Jun;4(3):337-343 [FREE Full text] [Medline]
- Ni H, Toy W, Burgess D, Wise K, Nauman DJ, Crispell K, et al. Comparative responsiveness of short-form 12 and Minnesota living with heart failure questionnaire in patients with heart failure. J Card Fail 2000 Jun;6(2):83-91. [Medline]
- Rector TS, Cohn JN. Assessment of patient outcome with the Minnesota living with heart failure questionnaire: reliability and validity during a randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled trial of pimobendan. Pimobendan multicenter research group. Am Heart J 1992 Oct;124(4):1017-1025. [Medline]
- McMurray JJ, Adamopoulos S, Anker SD, Auricchio A, Böhm M, Dickstein K, et al. ESC guidelines for the diagnosis and treatment of acute and chronic heart failure 2012: the task force for the diagnosis and treatment of acute and chronic heart failure 2012 of the European society of cardiology. Developed in collaboration with the heart failure association (HFA) of the ESC. Eur Heart J 2012 Jul;33(14):1787-1847 [FREE Full text] [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Keell SD, Chambers JS, Francis DP, Edwards DF, Stables RH. Shuttle-walk test to assess chronic heart failure. Lancet 1998 Aug 29;352(9129):705. [Medline]
- Rasekaba T, Lee AL, Naughton MT, Williams TJ, Holland AE. The six-minute walk test: a useful metric for the cardiopulmonary patient. Intern Med J 2009 Aug;39(8):495-501. [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Skorecki KL, Brenner BM. Body fluid homeostasis in man. A contemporary overview. Am J Med 1981 Jan;70(1):77-88. [Medline]
- Verbrugge FH, Dupont M, Steels P, Grieten L, Swennen Q, Tang WH, et al. The kidney in congestive heart failure: 'are natriuresis, sodium, and diuretics really the good, the bad and the ugly?'. Eur J Heart Fail 2014 Feb;16(2):133-142 [FREE Full text] [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Luft FC, Fineberg NS, Sloan RS. Estimating dietary sodium intake in individuals receiving a randomly fluctuating intake. Hypertension 1982;4(6):805-808 [FREE Full text] [Medline]
- Kang SS, Kang EH, Kim SO, Lee MS, Hong CD, Kim SB. Use of mean spot urine sodium concentrations to estimate daily sodium intake in patients with chronic kidney disease. Nutrition 2012 Mar;28(3):256-261. [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Ogura M, Kimura A, Takane K, Nakao M, Hamaguchi A, Terawaki H, et al. Estimation of salt intake from spot urine samples in patients with chronic kidney disease. BMC Nephrol 2012 Jun 08;13:36 [FREE Full text] [CrossRef] [Medline]
- McLean R, Williams S, Mann J. Monitoring population sodium intake using spot urine samples: validation in a New Zealand population. J Hum Hypertens 2014 Nov;28(11):657-662. [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Brown IJ, Dyer AR, Chan Q, Cogswell ME, Ueshima H, Stamler J, et al. Estimating 24-hour urinary sodium excretion from casual urinary sodium concentrations in Western populations: the INTERSALT study. Am J Epidemiol 2013 Jun 1;177(11):1180-1192 [FREE Full text] [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Averina VA, Othmer HG, Fink GD, Osborn JW. A new conceptual paradigm for the haemodynamics of salt-sensitive hypertension: a mathematical modelling approach. J Physiol 2012 Dec 01;590(23):5975-5992 [FREE Full text] [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Brown IJ, Tzoulaki I, Candeias V, Elliott P. Salt intakes around the world: implications for public health. Int J Epidemiol 2009 Jun;38(3):791-813 [FREE Full text] [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Mann SJ, Gerber LM. Estimation of 24-hour sodium excretion from spot urine samples. J Clin Hypertens (Greenwich) 2010 Mar;12(3):174-180 [FREE Full text] [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Kawano Y, Tsuchihashi T, Matsuura H, Ando K, Fujita T, Ueshima H, Working Group for Dietary Salt Reduction of the Japanese Society of Hypertension. Report of the working group for dietary salt reduction of the Japanese society of hypertension: (2) assessment of salt intake in the management of hypertension. Hypertens Res 2007 Oct;30(10):887-893. [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Verbrugge FH, Nijst P, Dupont M, Penders J, Tang WHW, Mullens W. Urinary composition during decongestive treatment in heart failure with reduced ejection fraction. Circ Heart Fail 2014 Sep;7(5):766-772. [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Ferreira JP, Girerd N, Medeiros PB, Santos M, Carvalho HC, Bettencourt P, et al. Spot urine sodium excretion as prognostic marker in acutely decompensated heart failure: the spironolactone effect. Clin Res Cardiol 2016 Jun;105(6):489-507. [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Heart Failure Society Of America. Nonpharmacologic management and health care maintenance in patients with chronic heart failure. J Card Fail 2006 Feb;12(1):e29-e37. [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Piotrowicz E, Baranowski R, Bilinska M, Stepnowska M, Piotrowska M, Wójcik A, et al. A new model of home-based telemonitored cardiac rehabilitation in patients with heart failure: effectiveness, quality of life, and adherence. Eur J Heart Fail 2010 Feb;12(2):164-171. [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Leidy N, Rentz A, Zyczynski T. Evaluating Health-related quality-of-life outcomes in patients with congestive heart failure. A review of recent randomised controlled trials. Pharmacoeconomics 1999;15:19-46. [Medline]
- Johnson G, Carson P, Francis GS, Cohn JN. Influence of prerandomization (baseline) variables on mortality and on the reduction of mortality by enalapril. Veterans Affairs Cooperative Study on Vasodilator Therapy of Heart Failure (V-HeFT II). V-HeFT VA Cooperative Studies Group. Circulation 1993 Jun;87(6 Suppl):VI32-VI39. [Medline]
- Garin O, Herdman M, Vilagut G, Ferrer M, Ribera A, Rajmil L, et al. Assessing health-related quality of life in patients with heart failure: a systematic, standardized comparison of available measures. Heart Fail Rev 2014 May;19(3):359-367. [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Rector TS, Tschumperlin LK, Kubo SH, Bank AJ, Francis GS, McDonald KM, et al. Use of the Living With Heart Failure questionnaire to ascertain patients' perspectives on improvement in quality of life versus risk of drug-induced death. J Card Fail 1995 Jun;1(3):201-206. [Medline]
- Hoekstra T, Jaarsma T, van VD, Hillege HL, Sanderman R, Lesman-Leegte I. Quality of life and survival in patients with heart failure. Eur J Heart Fail 2013 Jan;15(1):94-102 [FREE Full text] [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Wu RC, Thorpe K, Ross H, Micevski V, Marquez C, Straus SE. Comparing administration of questionnaires via the internet to pen-and-paper in patients with heart failure: randomized controlled trial. J Med Internet Res 2009;11(1):e3 [FREE Full text] [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Mentz RJ, Babyak MA, Bittner V, Fleg JL, Keteyian SJ, Swank AM, HF-ACTION Investigators. Prognostic significance of depression in blacks with heart failure: insights from heart failure: a controlled trial investigating outcomes of exercise training. Circ Heart Fail 2015 May;8(3):497-503 [FREE Full text] [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Chaudhry SI, Mattera JA, Curtis JP, Spertus JA, Herrin J, Lin Z, et al. Telemonitoring in patients with heart failure. N Engl J Med 2010 Dec 9;363(24):2301-2309 [FREE Full text] [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Scherr D, Kastner P, Kollmann A, Hallas A, Auer J, Krappinger H, MOBITEL Investigators. Effect of home-based telemonitoring using mobile phone technology on the outcome of heart failure patients after an episode of acute decompensation: randomized controlled trial. J Med Internet Res 2009 Aug 17;11(3):e34 [FREE Full text] [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Julious S. Sample size of 12 per group rule of thumb for a pilot study. Pharmaceutical Statistics 2005;4:287-291. [CrossRef]
- Curtis JP, Sokol SI, Wang Y, Rathore SS, Ko DT, Jadbabaie F, et al. The association of left ventricular ejection fraction, mortality, and cause of death in stable outpatients with heart failure. J Am Coll Cardiol 2003 Aug 20;42(4):736-742 [FREE Full text] [Medline]
- Curtis LH, Greiner MA, Hammill BG, Kramer JM, Whellan DJ, Schulman KA, et al. Early and long-term outcomes of heart failure in elderly persons, 2001-2005. Arch Intern Med 2008 Dec 08;168(22):2481-2488 [FREE Full text] [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Dunlay SM, Redfield MM, Weston SA, Therneau TM, Hall LK, Shah ND, et al. Hospitalizations after heart failure diagnosis a community perspective. J Am Coll Cardiol 2009 Oct 27;54(18):1695-1702 [FREE Full text] [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Neter E, Brainin E. eHealth literacy: extending the digital divide to the realm of health information. J Med Internet Res 2012 Jan;14(1):e19 [FREE Full text] [CrossRef] [Medline]
|ACEI: angiotensin-converting enzyme inhibitor|
|ACS: automatic call system|
|ARB: angiotensin receptor blocker|
|ARS: automatic response system|
|BP: blood pressure|
|CO2: carbon dioxide|
|EF: ejection fraction|
|GFR: glomerular filtration rate|
|HF: heart failure|
|ICT: information communication technology|
|LV: left ventricular|
|MLHFQ: Minnesota Living With Heart Failure Questionnaire|
|NT-proBNP: N-terminal prohormone of brain natriuretic peptide|
|NYHA: New York Heart Association|
|SE: standard error|
|SMS: short message service|
|TTS: text to speech|
|uNa: urine sodium concentration|
|WBC: white blood cell|
Edited by CL Parra-Calderón; submitted 28.11.16; peer-reviewed by H Ross, H Al-Samarraie; comments to author 07.02.17; revised version received 30.06.17; accepted 25.07.17; published 02.10.17
©Heesun Lee, Jun-Bean Park, Sae Won Choi, Yeonyee E Yoon, Hyo Eun Park, Sang Eun Lee, Seung-Pyo Lee, Hyung-Kwan Kim, Hyun-Jai Cho, Su-Yeon Choi, Hae-Young Lee, Jonghyuk Choi, Young-Joon Lee, Yong-Jin Kim, Goo-Yeong Cho, Jinwook Choi, Dae-Won Sohn. Originally published in JMIR Mhealth and Uhealth (http://mhealth.jmir.org), 02.10.2017.
This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work, first published in JMIR mhealth and uhealth, is properly cited. The complete bibliographic information, a link to the original publication on http://mhealth.jmir.org/, as well as this copyright and license information must be included.